A Parent’s Guide · Turning Winds Journal
Love and Logic on Reddit: Where Parents Say It Works, and Where It Breaks Down
Parents discuss the Love and Logic approach on Reddit constantly. What those threads get right about it, where it breaks down in practice, and what helps.
Troy, Montana20 min read
Parents often turn to online forums like Reddit when seeking information about the Love and Logic parenting approach. There, they find many discussions about the challenges and successes of using it with teenagers. A common theme emerges: teens often resist when they see “choices” as commands. Instead of cooperating, power struggles increase as teens challenge their parents or simply withdraw. A parent, for instance, might describe their teen refusing to pick from pre-approved options, seeing them as manipulative. One parent on Reddit even admitted contributing to the struggle themselves.
When Love and Logic is used too strictly, teens show similar patterns in school and with friends. In class, a teen might resist assignments or group work if they don’t have a say in the process, much like how they react to “choices” at home. Teachers who use Love and Logic say it works best when teens feel they have some control. Socially, these teens can struggle during disagreements with peers. They might seem inflexible or get frustrated when interactions don’t follow clear, predictable rules about what will happen next. This can lead to arguments or feeling left out.
In structured therapy settings, interactions with other teens reveal problems that match these home-life patterns. Teens often have trouble making decisions together, trying to dictate what the group does or blaming others when things don’t go well. They don’t accept shared responsibility. When natural consequences are discussed, some teens react emotionally, seeing them as punishment rather than logical results of their actions. Therapists notice these teens are often skeptical of the choices offered. They might look for hidden motives or refuse to participate, even in supportive environments.
Many parents seek professional help for ongoing arguments. They often feel exhausted, while their teens become more defiant or withdrawn. Communication breaks down. Teens meet their parents’ attempts at offering “choices” with cynicism or outright refusal. School performance can drop, and friendships become strained, leading to more isolation. Parents report feeling helpless, realizing that the intended benefits of Love and Logic, like teaching responsibility and building connection, aren’t happening. They look for support beyond online forums to fix their family dynamic.
What Reddit Gets Right About Love and Logic
Online discussions often highlight the core ideas of Love and Logic, emphasizing shared control and natural consequences. Parents report success when the approach genuinely empowers teens with choices, which helps them become more responsible. Teachers make similar observations. Many educators seek advice after reading the books, while others describe successfully using the method with various age groups. These discussions align with the framework’s main goal: to build connection, not just obedience, as explained by Dr. Foster Cline and Jim Fay.
Where Love and Logic Discussions on Reddit Miss the Mark
While Reddit discussions offer valuable insights, they sometimes lack a clinical perspective. They don’t always distinguish between using the approach effectively and applying it too rigidly. A thread titled “Is Love&Logic Abusive?” raises important concerns. When used without warmth or responsiveness, the structure of choices and consequences can start to feel like authoritarian parenting. This goes against the intended goal of shared control. Reddit forums often miss the difference between Love and Logic done well versus poorly. They don’t always provide a clear path for parents to figure out when the method is creating distance instead of connection, or when it’s time to seek professional help.
Love and Logic parents avoid the helicopter and drill sergeant mentalities by using a consultant style of parenting as early as possible in the child’s life. They ask their children questions and offer choices. Instead of telling their children what to do, they put the burden of decision-making on their kids’ shoulders.
Foster Cline, MD, and Jim Fay
Quick Summary
When used with care, Love and Logic helps teenagers feel more in control. It lets them learn from natural consequences, which builds responsibility. But if you apply it too strictly, without truly connecting, it can accidentally cause power struggles. This can feel more like strict, authoritarian parenting instead of the caring approach it’s meant to be. To achieve success, parents often need to step back from conflict and focus on “getting it right” rather than just “being right.”
- 02Where Reddit Finds Love and Logic Works
- 03Applying Principles for Quality Care
- 04Where Families and Reddit Often Get Stuck
- 05Turning the Approach Into Daily Habits
- 06When Love and Logic Isn’t Enough: Recognizing the Signs for Professional Help
- 07Your Role in Your Teen’s Healing: How Families Support Treatment
- 08Common Questions
- 09What You Can Do This Week
- 10Independently Accredited Care and Academics
02of 10
Where Reddit Finds Love and Logic Works
Parents frequently search Reddit for insights into Love and Logic. Many discussions there highlight the method’s effectiveness when it genuinely empowers children with control, fostering responsibility.a teacher on r/Teachers shared how they use Love and Logic in their classroom with all ages. They found it especially helpful for students who like to feel they have a say in their choices. This idea fits perfectly with the methods created by Dr. Foster Cline and Jim Fay.
Their approach supports sharing control and letting kids learn from the natural results of their actions. Likewise, a parent looking into gentle parenting on r/Parenting noticed something important. By using Love and Logic consistently from an early age, they avoided big power struggles. Their child tested limits much less often. This method helps teens become more self-reliant. It lets them experience the direct results of their decisions in a safe and caring space, which is a big part of helping them grow and learn good behavior.
Self-Guided Observation
Over the last two weeks, ask yourself:
- Does your child consistently refuse choices presented during disagreements?
- Does your child regularly escalate when given options?
- Do consequences seem to make little difference in future actions?
- Does your child frequently become more defiant after a consequence?
- Is your child increasingly sad or anxious after consequences?
If you checked off several of these points, it might be time to talk to an expert. Turning Winds’ admissions counselors are ready to help, day or night, and your call is private. Call (800) 845-1380.
If your teen is in immediate danger or talking about suicide or self-harm, call or text 988 right now, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, available 24/7.
Applying Principles for Quality Care
The Love and Logic model, many experts and parents agree, truly works by focusing on building connections rather than mere obedience.
Turning Winds stresses that in any disagreement, the goal should be “getting it right,” not “winning.” This is a core idea for providing good care. You can see the continued interest in how to use these ideas in real life in another r/Teachers thread. There, an educator asked for practical advice after reading “Teaching with Love and Logic.” This method encourages parents to show empathy before giving consequences. It means you acknowledge your teen’s feelings, even when you need to set limits. In his book “Not by Chance,” Dr. Tim Thayne explains how important it is for parents to step away from power struggles. This allows teens to take responsibility for their own choices. This kind of caring approach greatly improves parenting with empathy and understanding. It goes beyond just managing behavior. Instead, it helps build stronger relationships and trust within the family, which is essential for a healthy family life.
Where Families and Reddit Often Get Stuck
While Love and Logic holds great potential, Reddit discussions also reveal where families can struggle. This often occurs when the approach’s structure is misunderstood, leading some to perceive it as a strict parenting style lacking warmth or flexibility. Discussions frequently touch on these concerns.“Is Love&Logic Abusive?” on r/Parenting brings up an important point. It argues that if the Love&Logic method is used without real warmth and care, it can accidentally feel like very strict parenting. This is a key difference many people miss. The program is meant to give both parents and kids some control, not to be an excuse for parents to step back.
For example, in one online post about power struggles, a parent of a 14-year-old daughter openly admitted their own actions made the conflict worse. This shows how important it is for parents to understand their role when the method isn’t working. The main problem happens when parents focus only on the “logic” of consequences and forget the “love” of connection.
This can turn choices into demands. When this happens, it stops teens from truly learning to be responsible. Instead of helping them grow, it can build anger. For families dealing with these kinds of challenges, knowing how a program works closely with a child’s school can provide steady support. This helps avoid common mistakes.
The overlook
Love and Logic thrives on connection, not control.
When applied with genuine empathy and shared decision-making, it builds responsibility. But rigid application can lead to power struggles and defiance.
Turning the Approach Into Daily Habits
Making these new ideas part of your daily routine takes practice. But the reward is a calmer home and stronger family connections. It’s all about making small, steady changes in how you talk and act with your child.
A powerful change comes from the Love and Logic approach. This method encourages parents to give choices whenever you can. Instead of ordering, “Put on your shoes,” try asking, “Would you like to wear your sneakers or your boots today?” This simple question gives your child a feeling of having some control, which can cut down on arguments.
Love and Logic also suggests letting natural consequences teach lessons, always with understanding. If your child leaves their backpack out and forgets their homework, you might say, “Oh, that’s tough that you don’t have your homework. What can we do tomorrow to make sure this doesn’t happen again?” This is much more helpful than giving a lecture.
When arguments start to get intense, remember the advice from Tim Thayne, PhD, in his book Not by Chance. He tells parents to step away from power struggles instead of getting caught up in them. This means you calmly state what you expect or your rule, then you stop arguing. This allows your child to face the results of their choices without you getting pulled into a long back-and-forth. Consider this: if your child insists on wearing shorts when it’s cold, you could say, “It’s cold enough for pants, but you can choose. If you’re cold later, we’ll talk about it then.” After that, let the discussion go.
Finally, remember that an argument can pull both of you into proving a point instead of solving the problem. When you feel a power struggle starting, take a moment. Ask yourself: Are you trying to win this argument, or are you trying to find a solution?
Changing your goal to “getting it right” – finding a solution that works for everyone – can completely change the situation. You might, for instance, say, “We both want a clean room. How can we make that happen so it works for both of us?” This way of thinking focuses on working together instead of fighting, which builds stronger bonds instead of pushing people apart.
When Love and Logic Isn’t Enough: Recognizing the Signs for Professional Help
Love and Logic offers wonderful ways to help parents guide their teens and teach them responsibility. But even the best parenting strategies have their limits. Sometimes, a teen’s struggles go beyond normal growing pains or the usual reactions to consequences. These are moments when your child might need professional help. It’s not a sign you’ve failed as a parent; instead, it shows deep love and courage to get your child the support they truly need.
Start thinking about professional help if you notice big, lasting changes that affect your teen’s daily life for several weeks or months. This could be a dramatic shift in their mood, like constant sadness, being easily annoyed, or losing interest in things they once loved. Also, pay attention to changes in sleep (too much or too little), appetite, personal hygiene, or a sudden, unexplained drop in school grades or refusing to go to school.
Other important signs include pulling away from friends and family, constant worry that gets in the way of daily life, or an increase in risky behaviors like using drugs or alcohol, or self-harm. If these patterns appear, and you feel more and more helpless, or your family life is constantly stressed despite your best efforts, it’s time to get a professional evaluation.
This means talking to your teen’s doctor, a school counselor, or a therapist who works with teenagers. These experts can tell the difference between typical teen ups and downs and real mental health concerns. They will guide you to the right support. Getting outside help shows you are actively committed to your teen’s well-being, making sure they get the special care needed to handle tough challenges and truly succeed.
As parents, we want to raise strong, adaptable teens. But sometimes, life throws challenges that are too big for family strategies alone. When a teenager is struggling with mental health issues, professional therapy offers clear paths to healing and healthy growth.
Often, individual therapy is the main support. It uses proven methods like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) or Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT). These therapies help teens spot unhelpful ways of thinking, understand their feelings, and learn practical skills. They teach how to handle stress, control impulses, and deal with tough situations effectively. The main goal is for teens to understand themselves better and gain tools they can use for life.
However, a teen’s struggles rarely happen in a vacuum. Family therapy steps in, recognizing that these challenges are often tied to the whole family. This team approach brings everyone together. It helps improve communication, sort out disagreements, and create a more supportive and understanding home.
New studies, like a 2024 report on attachment-based family therapy for teen depression, highlight how much stronger family connections and better communication can help struggling teens. By working on these core family patterns, therapists help build a strong unit where everyone feels heard and valued. This greatly supports the teen’s healing journey.Group therapy offers another important kind of help. Here, teens connect with peers who understand what they’re going through. Sharing experiences makes them feel less alone and helps them understand others better. It’s also a safe place to practice new ways of talking and connecting.
The most effective treatment often combines these different types of therapy: individual, family, and group sessions. This creates a complete plan of care. This full approach helps your teen grow as a whole person. It teaches them to manage their feelings, make good choices, and build strong ways to handle stress. These skills will empower them in every part of their life.
When you look for professional help, it’s crucial to choose licensed professionals and programs that use methods proven to work. Don’t hesitate to ask important questions: What does the treatment plan involve? How will your family be actively involved? What training and experience does the therapy team have?
For example, understanding the program’s core beliefs, often set by its medical director and clinical programming director, like Dr. John Gordon and Jared Sartell, LCSW – can give you key insights into their approach. Remember, real change takes time and commitment; there are no quick fixes. But with the right professional guidance, your teen can develop the skills to not just cope, but to truly thrive.
“There is another element to why good programs work, and that is simply time. To create deep internal change, teens need to be immersed in a carefully crafted milieu, with positive values and solid principles, long enough for these changes to sink in.”
07of 10
Your Role in Your Teen’s Healing: How Families Support Treatment
When your teenager is struggling with their mental health or behavior, it’s natural to focus only on what they’re going through. But real, lasting healing rarely happens alone. Your family is the most important place your teen spends their time every day. This means your active involvement in their treatment isn’t just helpful, it’s absolutely vital.
As a parent or guardian, you’re not just watching from the sidelines. You are a key partner in their healing journey. You offer a steady presence and a unique understanding of your teen’s past and personality. This means attending family sessions, learning new ways to interact, and being open to changing routines and expectations at home.
Family therapy offers a structured, safe space to look at family patterns that might be adding to your teen’s difficulties. It’s a chance for everyone to share their thoughts, understand each other’s needs, and work together to find solutions. During these guided sessions, families can learn better ways to communicate. This includes listening actively, expressing feelings clearly without blame, and setting healthy boundaries. These skills directly improve daily life, helping to calm conflicts and build deeper connections. When everyone understands their part in creating a healthier family, the whole household benefits.
Beyond the therapy room, creating a consistently supportive home environment is crucial. This means setting up predictable routines, clear expectations, and consequences that are given with both empathy and firmness, much like the Love and Logic approach. It involves acknowledging your teen’s feelings while also holding them responsible for their actions. A home that encourages open talks, where mistakes are seen as chances to learn, and where your teen feels understood and safe to express themselves without judgment can greatly support the therapy work. This helps new, positive behaviors truly stick.
Remember, healing takes time, and your patience and persistence are incredibly valuable. Look for treatment providers who actively involve families, offering parent education or coaching along with individual and family therapy. Ask potential programs how they involve families and how they help parents use new strategies at home. Your commitment to learning and growing alongside your teen will not only strengthen your relationship but also give your whole family strong tools for future challenges. This ensures the benefits of treatment last long into the future.
Navigating the world of mental health when your teen is struggling can feel overwhelming. It’s not just about finding any therapist; it’s about finding the right one, someone who truly connects with teenagers and fits your family’s values.
To start, thoroughly check their qualifications. Ask about their license, their specific training in adolescent psychology, and how long they’ve worked with young people facing challenges similar to your child’s. A professional who is a good match will be open about their background and happy to discuss their expertise. This includes their experience with issues like anxiety, depression, or specific behaviors that worry you. Once you feel good about their background, it’s time to explore their therapy approach. What methods do they use?
When choosing a therapist, ask if their methods are backed by research. Find out how they adjust their approach for teenagers, considering their unique stage of development. It’s also crucial to understand how they involve families. As parents who believe in Love and Logic, you know your role is vital. Will they include you in sessions, offer parent coaching, or suggest separate family therapy?
Be careful if a therapist insists on keeping parents completely out of the loop without a very good reason. Teen therapy often works best when the whole family works together. Knowing the basics of positive parenting can help you decide if their methods fit your family’s goals. Beyond how they work, practical details are important too.
Make sure to discuss how often sessions will be, how long they last, the cost, and how they handle insurance. A good professional will be upfront about their fees and rules from the start. Just as important is watching how they communicate. Do they truly listen to your worries, or do your questions feel brushed aside? Be cautious of anyone who promises “quick fixes” or guarantees certain results.
Real progress takes time and effort. A skilled therapist will clearly explain their process, talk openly about your teen’s progress, and be willing to work with others, like a school counselor or pediatrician, when needed. Most importantly, trust your gut feeling. A strong connection with a therapist is built on mutual respect and clear, steady communication.
Parents have this intense emotional attachment to their kids, and sometimes that causes them to parent from an emotional standpoint, not a logical one.
Foster Cline
Love and Logic: Effective vs. Rigid Application
Effective Love & Logic
Building connection, shared control, responsibility
Rigid Love & Logic
Can lead to power struggles, defiance, withdrawal
Common Questions
What are the common criticisms of Love and Logic?
Some people, especially on Reddit, say Love and Logic can feel like manipulation if parents aren’t truly sincere. Children might sense they don’t have real choices. This approach also requires parents to be very consistent, which can be tiring. Others feel it doesn’t always go deep enough to help with serious behavior problems or the needs of kids with neurodivergent conditions, unless it’s adjusted. A child might even say, “You’re just giving me choices you already decided,” which can break down trust.
What is the “7-7-7 rule” for parents?
The “7-7-7 rule” suggests parents spend 7 minutes each day, for 7 days a week, over 7 weeks, giving their child their full, positive attention. This isn’t a main part of Love and Logic. However, it fits well with building strong relationships, which is key to any good parenting method. For example, spending just 7 minutes playing a board game together daily can strengthen your bond. This makes your child more open to your guidance.
Does Love and Logic work for children with ADHD?
Yes, Love and Logic can be helpful for children with ADHD. It offers clear structure and steady, calm consequences, which often benefit these kids. However, parents on Reddit point out that it takes extra patience. You’ll also need to adjust choices to be simpler and more direct. For instance, instead of many complex options, offer two very clear choices, like “finish homework now or after dinner.” This can help manage impulsivity and prevent your child from feeling overwhelmed.
Is Love and Logic a strict parenting style?
Love and Logic isn’t about being mean or overly strict. Instead, it focuses on setting clear rules calmly, without anger or threats. This approach helps kids learn from their own choices and the natural results that follow, teaching them to be responsible. Grown-ups set the boundaries, but children get a real say within those limits, which helps them learn to manage themselves. For instance, instead of just telling your child to clean their room, you might say, “Before screen time, you can either clean your room or help with the dishes.”
How do parents tell the difference between normal independence-seeking and a real problem?
It’s normal for teens to want more independence. This often looks like them wanting to make their own choices, but they still keep up with their chores and hobbies, like picking out their own clothes. However, a real problem shows up differently. You might see a big drop in how they manage daily life, a loss of interest in things they used to love, or ongoing sadness or worry that gets in the way of everyday activities. If your teen stops going to school or cuts off all their friends for several weeks, it’s a sign to get professional help. This is different from just testing limits.
How do parents distinguish typical teen moodiness from clinical mental health issues?
Normal teen moodiness usually doesn’t last long and doesn’t stop them from doing everyday things. For example, they might be grumpy sometimes but still finish their homework. But mental health problems are different. These involve strong, ongoing feelings of sadness or worry that make it hard to function in many parts of their life, and they last for more than two weeks. If your teen’s sadness keeps them from going to school or seeing friends for a long time, it’s important to get a professional opinion. This is how you tell the difference between a passing bad mood and something more serious.
Why do some parents on Reddit say Love and Logic doesn’t work for their strong-willed child?
Some kids who are very strong-willed might push back against the limited choices offered by Love and Logic. This can happen if the method wasn’t started when they were younger, or if the child always blames others instead of taking responsibility. This approach works best when a child accepts responsibility for their actions. It can be tough if they see the choices as you trying to trick them, instead of chances to learn and grow. For example, if your child won’t pick between two outfits, you might need to calmly say, “Then I will choose for you this time,” and then actually do it.
What are common mistakes parents make when trying to use Love and Logic?
Parents sometimes make a few common mistakes when trying Love and Logic. One big error is using it as punishment, giving consequences with anger or long lectures instead of with calm understanding. Another mistake is giving too many choices, or offering options you’re not truly okay with your child picking. This can make your child lose trust in you. For instance, if you ask, “Do you want to clean your room or not?” but “not” isn’t really an option, you’re giving a fake choice.
How does Love and Logic help with sibling conflict, according to Reddit users?
Love and Logic helps kids work out their own small disagreements. It gives them the power to make choices and learn from what naturally happens, instead of parents always stepping in. This method teaches important skills for solving problems and means parents don’t have to be the constant referee, helping kids become more independent. For example, if siblings are fighting over a toy, a parent could calmly say, “You two need to find a fair way to share, or the toy will be put away for a bit.”
When should parents consider professional help if Love and Logic isn’t working?
If you’ve been consistently using Love and Logic and it’s not helping your child’s behavior, or if their issues get much worse, like severe distress, aggression, or self-harm, it’s very important to get professional help. Watch for signs such as ongoing defiance, very strong emotional outbursts, or pulling away from all activities, even after you’ve tried your best. If you are concerned about self-harm or suicide, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) or 911 immediately.
What You Can Do This Week
Reflect on how you’re currently using Love and Logic and how your teen responds. Ask yourself if the “consequences” you’re giving are truly logical and delivered with understanding, or if they sometimes feel like punishment or lead to power struggles. A good way to start a conversation might be: “I’ve been thinking about how we handle [specific situation]. How does that feel for you when [consequence] happens?”
Identify specific areas where Love and Logic might not be working for your family. Other parents on Reddit have shared similar experiences. This could be because of your teen’s unique personality, a misunderstanding of the method, or the need to adjust it for more complex issues beyond simple behavior. Focus on understanding the why behind the struggle.
Recognize when your teen needs professional support. Look for a big, ongoing increase in arguments or defiance, even after you’ve tried your best. Another sign is a noticeable drop in your teen’s mood, social life, or school grades, especially if it seems tied to constant power struggles. Also, pay attention if your teen talks about feeling hopeless or worthless, beyond just normal teenage ups and downs. If you see these signs, talk to your pediatrician or a licensed mental health provider to ask for an evaluation. Turning Winds offers parents a chance to have a detailed, unhurried conversation about their family’s unique situation. Since 2002, they’ve spoken with thousands of families during admissions calls, helping people from every state and every continent for over two decades, whether or not those families went on to enroll.
Act immediately if your teen is in immediate danger or talking about suicide. You can call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (available 24/7) to connect with trained crisis counselors.
Independently Accredited Care and Academics
I have a really amazing relationship with my family. I have honest relationships that I don’t have to take from them. So, I can have their love and care, and it’s not transactional, and that’s really beautiful.
Andrew
Related Podcasts
World-Renowned Dr. Foster Cline, Pioneer of Love and Logic, on Raising Responsible Teens
Every discussion referenced on this page is a real, public Reddit thread. We link them so you can read the conversations in full, the advice there is unfiltered and unvetted; the perspective on this page is ours.
- Is Love&Logic Abusive?
r/Parenting · notable
- Gentle Parenting / Love and Logic
r/Parenting · notable
- I’m having a hard time with the power struggle
r/parentingteenagers · notable
- Anyone using Love and Logic?
r/Teachers · notable
- Just finished “Teaching with Love and Logic” – has anyone used it?
r/Teachers · notable
Reddit is a trademark of Reddit, Inc., which is not affiliated with and does not endorse Turning Winds.
Exploring whether your teen needs more support?
If weekly therapy hasn’t been enough, it can be helpful to learn about what more complete support options look like before you make any decisions.
Joint Commission accredited · Confidential · Most major insurance accepted
3 sources listed below